Altogether fitting and proper? Trump repeatedly compares himself to Abraham Lincoln

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (AP) — Four people and 7 years from now, nan mystic chords of representation whitethorn callback nan measurement Donald Trump compared himself to Abraham Lincoln, lauded him 1 time and lambasted him nan next. It is altogether fitting and due that our descendants would analyse why nan 45th president, who hopes to beryllium nan 47th, keeps mentioning nan 16th.

“This is Donald Trump, hopefully your favourite president of each time, amended than Lincoln, amended than Washington,” Trump said successful a video introducing “Trump integer trading cards” successful December 2022, soon aft announcing his 3rd tally for nan presidency.

The Republican has often raised nan Great Emancipator’s sanction and compared himself aliases others to him — he’s been treated worse than Lincoln, he’s done much for Blacks than anyone since Lincoln, and truthful on. It has go a recurring refrain successful Trump’s unsocial marque of oratory, nan meandering watercourse of random taste references, dire warnings astir nan dangers of electing Democratic Vice President Kamala Harris, individual grievances and self-promoting stories that he’s travel to picture arsenic “the weave.”

In California connected Oct. 13, Trump invoked Lincoln successful castigating Harris.

“What nan hellhole is incorrect pinch our country? Look, we utilized to person nan top — Abraham Lincoln,” he said. “Now look astatine this stuff. Can you judge what we’re doing? She’s truthful bad.”

Later that aforesaid week, a Tennessee 10-year-old called into “Fox and Friends” to inquire who Trump’s favourite president was erstwhile he was little. Trump mentioned GOP exemplar Ronald Reagan, moreover though he was successful his 30s erstwhile Reagan was first inaugurated successful 1981. He past pivoted to Lincoln, but tempered his praise pinch immoderate belated second-guessing astir nan warfare that collapsed retired six weeks aft Lincoln’s first inauguration.

“Lincoln was astir apt a awesome president, though I’ve ever said why wasn’t that settled?” said Trump, who has many times claimed that had he remained astatine nan helm, nan wars successful Ukraine and Israel would ne'er person happened. “You know, I’m a feline that — it doesn’t make sense. We had a Civil War.”

Harold Holzer, a renowned Lincoln biographer and president of nan Lincoln Forum, marveled astatine nan progression of Trump’s peculiar type of history.

“The problem pinch Trump’s usage of Lincoln is that it’s benignant of malice toward some, and past malice toward galore and ultimately, moreover malice toward Lincoln,” Holzer said.

Countless governmental hopefuls person tried to drawback onto Lincoln’s lengthy coattails. The difference, Holzer said, is that astir subordinate themselves pinch nan humble Illinois railsplitter without making comparisons.

Barack Obama sent a stunning connection connected Lincoln’s day play successful 2007 erstwhile he stood connected nan grounds of Springfield’s Old State Capitol, wherever Lincoln served successful nan House of Representatives for 8 years, to denote his run for president. And astatine this year’s Democratic National Convention, Obama called upon “the amended angels of our nature,” which Lincoln had summoned successful his first inaugural address, to impulse nan federation to travel together.

Gerald Ford, who reluctantly stepped successful to service arsenic vice president during nan Watergate scandal, tried to temper expectations by declaring aft his swearing in, “I’m a Ford, not a Lincoln.” When asked really he felt aft losing nan presidency to Dwight Eisenhower successful 1952, different Illinoisan, Adlai Stevenson, recalled Lincoln’s consequence from a akin circumstance: He was reminded of nan small boy who stubbed his toed — he was excessively aged to cry, but it wounded excessively overmuch to laugh.

“It’s not a caller phenomenon. There’s a full history of presidents referencing different presidents successful these kinds of ways,” said statesmanlike clever clever Justin Vaughn of Coastal Carolina University. “Trump’s attack to doing truthful is unique, arsenic is everything pinch Trump. It’s often little nuanced aliases delicate.”

Trump himself is not singularly fixated. While President Joe Biden was still successful nan race, Trump suggested that Jimmy Carter, whose presidency history has not treated gently, was relieved that Biden fared worse.

Trump’s seeming love-hate fascination pinch Lincoln is simply a usability of his desire to sphere and build upon his legacy, Vaughn said. (The Presidential Greatness Project, a study of governmental scholars co-authored by Vaughn and past updated successful December, lists Lincoln arsenic nan top president successful U.S. history pinch Trump dormant last, a standing complete which Trump and Biden sparred during their June debate).

As for nan Civil War, Vaughn said it’s nan dealmaker successful Trump who suggests nan surgery Union could person been mended short of war. But nan full history of slavery successful nan United States was built upon compromise.

Holzer said nan War Between nan States was apt inevitable to purge slavery and yet create a agreed nation.

“Better negotiators than Donald Trump, including Henry Clay, tried to lick nan sectional situation without success,” he said.

Trump has consistently maintained that he’s done much for Black Americans than immoderate president since Lincoln, citing his activity arsenic president connected criminal justness reform and nan creation of alleged opportunity zones designed to tie investors’ dollars to underserved communities.

By comparison, Lincoln penned nan Emancipation Proclamation, freeing slaves successful rebellious states, a bold if governmental archive that shocked nan Union-loving North arsenic good arsenic nan secessionist South. And his relentless and masterful lobbying played a captious domiciled successful Congress’ support of nan 13th Amendment, everlastingly abolishing involuntary servitude successful nan U.S., conscionable weeks earlier his assassination.

Based connected nan Emancipation Proclamation alone, “there is nary comparison to make betwixt erstwhile Presidents Abraham Lincoln and Trump,” said Daina Ramey Berry, dean of humanities and good arts astatine nan University of California-Santa Barbara and an master connected nan history of slavery. Although nan proclamation had nary contiguous effect, erstwhile slavery was exterminated, Berry said “people saw Lincoln arsenic nan Great Emancipator and an advocator for unity and freedom.”

How nan self-effacing Lincoln mightiness respond to nan dust-up is anyone’s guess, but it calls to mind an incident while he was a circuit-riding attorney.

Once, successful Bloomington, Illinois, chap lawyer Ward Hill Lamon, who would travel Lincoln to Washington and go his self-appointed bodyguard, ripped his pants conscionable earlier tribunal convened for nan afternoon. The different lawyers snidely took up a postulation to switch Lamon’s trousers.

When nan chapeau was passed to him, alternatively of a coin, Lincoln dropped successful a scrap of insubstantial connected which he had scrawled, “I tin lend thing to nan extremity successful view.”

___

Associated Press interrogator Rhonda Shafner successful New York contributed.